Career Theory – Introduction and Concepts
On this page:
What is theory?When people say “theory”, they usually mean any of the items above but most of the time they are thinking about a premise; “I have this theory of how this works…” they will say. Let’s briefly unpick theory in the context of career theory:
Premise:This is the initial idea, which can be a thought, a hunch, an idea, an observation or anything that catches the eye or mind and indicates something new about a situation. Usually, a conclusion follows a premise. In the case of career theory, this will be a new or different approach, based on a worked-out theory.
Theory:Builds upon, or challenges and adapts, the previously stated premise. See the example in the pyramid. This is where the premise will be worked out in more detail, based on evidence and offered as a foundation for a new or different approach and tools with which to apply career guidance, support, coaching or counselling.
Approach:One step on from a theory, we will have to think about how we are going to approach career support from the perspective of the premise and theory. How can you mould the theory or the findings in a more practical shape or angle you can actually use within career guidance? (also see below for an expansion on this).
Tools:having an approach is all nice and well but what are you going to use with clients to apply this approach? This is where we have to develop the tools to apply the approach, based on the theory which started out with an idea or premise. When you hear people say “I have a theory”, as mentioned, this could mean any of the 4 components above or all of them together. A lot of the time, ‘theory’ means an idea of how something works, without much evidence. Hopefully the explanation and graphic above has put ‘theory’ in a more useful context for career guidance work and self-reflection or reflection on practice. It’s important to be aware of the distinction, but the 4 elements above also offer a very good structure for critiquing any theory: Have a look on the web to see whether you can find a good working definition of ‘theory’. Are any of them useful for career guidance? At least they will have you start thinking about the different elements that come into the word ‘theory’.
Theories? Models? Approach? Eh? I’m confused…Don’t be! Here’s one interpretation of the difference within the context of career guidance:
TheoryTheory is used to explain broad structures or underpinning ideas based on evidence and is less ‘applied’ – e.g.: structural theory – career planning is influenced or determined by social structure. See the second tier of the pyramid above. Theory refers to erm… ‘theoretical structures’ rather than ‘practical structures’, which means it describes background, away from how this background is applied practically in career guidance, although we do build tools based on theories.
ModelA Model is used to offer a very practical structure, sometimes step by step, around which to build an intervention or interventions with clients in a very practical way – eg.: Egan’s model of career guidance:It’s directly related to how we work with clients and often/always has some instruction on how to work with clients generally or specifically.
ApproachAn approach, in my interpretation, envelopes both of the above and is about how you use theories and models in your work. It’s about how you approach the client’s queries, issues, needs, etc… using a mosaic of theories, models and techniques that resonate with the client and helps them, but within that, also resonates with who we are. It’s your own style of working or the way you approach the work you do. Of course, this is bound up not just with the client’s needs but also with our own background, context, skillset, character, personality and talents. Approach in this sense is the ‘professional artistry‘ Schön talks about in his work.
- Super’s Developmental Theory
- The DOTS model
Evaluating Theory – ScopeHow far does a theory reach? That is what is meant by scope. This is a very useful tool for evaluating theories and generally, scope is linked to detail. The more a theory or model envelops, the less it will deal well with detail if the theory is used in its pure form.
Some theories have a long reach
- Give you an excellent general overview
- Are not good at giving you a lot of detail
Other theories have more limited reach
- Are limited in distance they can take you
- allows you to explore every bit of detail with the client
Supporting – Enabling – Empowering
Choosing between theoriesBrown identified certain criteria for assessing theories and choosing theories for practice. These can be very useful in developing, or sharpening, your own mind when it comes to career theories and their usefulness for you as a career professional :
Explanation of the different items:
- Accessibility: a theory should be easy to understand and follow, succinct and elegant.
- Influence: a good theory influences others working in the same field. How prevalent is the theory and how far does it reach?
- Comprehensiveness: theory should include all and explain and predict a wide range of concepts, structures and processes in society.
- Causality: a good theory should explain phenomena and processes in terms of cause and effect. Are there any inconsistencies or claims without foundation?
- Guide to practice: what is the implication of the theory for practice? Can it easily be translated in an approach and possibly tools to use with clients?
- Relevance: a good theory should be relevant to life, society and how people act, behave, plan and make decisions in the real world.
- Brown, D. (1990) ‘Summary, comparison & critique of the major theories’, in Brown, D., Brooks, L. & Associates (Eds), Career Choice & Development, 2nd Edition, San Francisco, Jossey Bass, pp 338-363.
- Brown, D. and Brooks, L. (1996) ‘Introduction to Theories of Career Development and Choice; Origins, Evolution and Current Efforts’, in Brown, D., Brooks, L. & Associates (Eds), Career Choice & Development, 3rd Edition, San Francisco, Jossey Bass, pp 5-13.